I don't really trust anyone's claim so far =S
Obviously Hunter's causing chaos and then claims a ridiculously powerful role, which is why I don't trust him or his claim.
Alpha's claim just didn't seem right at the time, which makes it not quite trustworthy, but I feel that there are more dangerous people we need to deal with.
I suppose your claim, Notty, would make some sort of sense if it's survivor/cop, which I think you said somewhere you had to survive with town to win, but I'm almost certain there's plenty more you're not telling us =p
Duffie worries me because of the confidence he's been exuding through his posts. It might be part of an intimidation factor, or maybe I'm just being paranoid, but either way I'm keeping an eye on him