Infected_alien8_ ur being incredibly quiet for the amount of information going on, sure u don't want to stick ur dick in this cake?
imagine being awake before 4pm
if you want my opinion on the theory crafting, i think most of the suggestions are plausible except like converting town to 3p since i think stranger would likely consider that unbalanced. but in general, given this is stranger's first game without a co-host there's a lot of room for theories that might have flaws in them since everyone's first game is flawed somehow, so imo plenty of the theories people have suggested are possible even if they don't seem fully balanced
i could see alisha's idea being a thing with the idea behind the setup being that the devil gets to choose his team from the sinners based on who they are as a person + the abilities they're offering, maybe with extra measures in place for balance like the devil has to meet a certain requirement before they can accept someone's deal. for example the devil could have to do certain things to unlock the ability to recruit another teammate, e.g. give up his investigation immunity to unlock teammate 1, place the first vote of a lynch that goes through to unlock teammate 2. and maybe if devil is lynched day 0 they auto recruit 1 sinner so that the game doesn't end immediately, and maybe there's town roles that stranger thought would help keep the alignment conversion from being too OP e.g. 2 cops or something.
i could also see sessy's idea of the devil being 3p and having both town + mafia sinners trying to make deals with them being a thing, with the drawback being something like making them vulnerable to being silenced for a day, or it works kinda like the epicmafia alien role where they get marked for the devil after taking the deal and if all players left alive at some point in the game are marked, the devil steals the win, and that's what the drawback is
i could also see the devil being maf with two 'voodoo community' roles as its mafia team already, and that making deals is a mixture of good/bad for scum/town.
maybe the devil can force you to making a deal using the voodoo roles - though i don't think that has to be the case, and i could see stranger just thinking players would sometimes opt to making a deal with the devil themselves - since whilst you, aqua, wouldn't ever risk it, you can't assume that stranger thought everyone would come to that same conclusion
ultimately i think plenty of possibilities are possible at this point, i dont think spending all day discussing it is gonna get us far this early in the game so i'm mostly putting my attention on scumhunting
wow look who's downplaying all the knowledge of mafia mechanics they have!!!
unvote
vote Vatumok
same this post rubbed me the wrong way too
If you're not the devil ingame then you are at least the devil IRL ?
All I'm saying is I'm not really used to the way of chatting on forums and wild setups that these closed forum games can have.
I did give some of my reads already. To add to that, sessy, hk and skele seem most sus at this time. It would make sense for there to be like 1 devil and perhaps 2 teammates in a 12p game.
even if you're not used to it i think you'd ordinarily be easily able to judge what seems plausible/contribute ideas for how the setup could be so this feels like a fake excuse to me
also skele hasn't even said anything other than saying hi right at the start ?
Mostly just intuition, there's not much I can go off so early in the game. With skele for example I would've expected him to post something already if he wasn't scum.
why?