[GAME OVER - TOWN WIN] The Comedy Club

[webpaige]

filthy lies!

Is
that
a
slip

que!

The Darkness

 

[Nottykitten]

I guess it's all up to Tim then.

proven how

Both Alisha and Ltin have confirmed to not get items on the nights ive purified them.

coin flips cheapen our convictions in what we think are right and make it more difficult to gather reads based on what happened

i believe notty slightly more than hk but i also was wrong about stranger and am willing to consider the possibility i am wrong, and would rather avoid leaving it up to chance if at all possible

But this is an easy way to have the scum manipulate your vote. If Tim votes Hk again and Ltin comes on and leaves me with 4 votes too why would you switch to me instead of taking the 50/50 that the person you actually want to vote gets lynched. We'll learn just as much from the votes if it goes down to a 50/50 but atleast your vote isn't manipulated by others in that scenario

 

[webpaige]

this is where it turns out both hk and notty are town and this is a giant mess and the mafia are laughing at us

Then we riot for having USELESS town powers!

 

[Alisha]

but how
for you personally you get a 50% chance you get the outcome you want and a 50% chance you get the outcome you don't (want as much)
otherwise its a 100% chance to get the outcome you don't want (as much)
i dont see how you would be willing to sacrifice your convictions but then also justify this as showing conviction

an outcome as a result of chance is tainted by that scum could push for a tie so they can leave it to chance and be able to make excuses for how the result swung any which way, which gives less reads and makes it impossible to tell who is scum or town in any situation as a result of a coin flip

yes my conviction is that its probably hk but i know myself to potentially be incorrect here and so i would rather avoid a chance based outcome based on the above

 

[webpaige]

Both Alisha and Ltin have confirmed to not get items on the nights ive purified them.

For all we know you told the Darkness to murder the others with your spirit powers too

 

[Mooglie]

Is
that
a
slip

how!
if i thought notty was mafia and hk wasn't then i'd be voting hk
thus i dont think notty is mafia and thus not all of them can be mafia!

The Darkness

que i dont see how this relates to why mafia wouldnt have comedians!

Then we riot for having USELESS town powers!

@ stranger

 

[Nottykitten]

Tim is there anything you want to hear from me to make you more confident in voting Hk again

 

[Mooglie]

an outcome as a result of chance is tainted by that scum could push for a tie so they can leave it to chance and be able to make excuses for how the result swung any which way, which gives less reads and makes it impossible to tell who is scum or town in any situation as a result of a coin flip

yes my conviction is that its probably hk but i know myself to potentially be incorrect here and so i would rather avoid a chance based outcome based on the above

i do not understand this at all!
like i generally cannot understand

 

[Mooglie]

like i generally cannot understand

*genuinely

i read that 3 times thinking 'something is wrong' then posted it and realised 30 secs later

 

[Alisha]

i do not understand this at all!
like i generally cannot understand

well i dont understand why people would leave outcomes to a coin flip!

 

[Mooglie]

well i dont understand why people would leave outcomes to a coin flip!

since you get 50% chance you believe in and 50% chance you dont

+ its fun to imagine the timeline splitting at that moment and then we look back at end of game and imagine what would happen in the alternate timeline

 

[Alisha]

since you get 50% chance you believe in and 50% chance you dont

+ its fun to imagine the timeline splitting at that moment and then we look back at end of game and imagine what would happen in the alternate timeline

you can do that without coin flips!

 

[Mooglie]

you can do that without coin flips!

but then the event isnt random its by someone making an actual choice!

 

[webpaige]

@ stranger

Be notified of how many of each loot item the people in your current room are collectively carrying overall.

Everyone who isn't a comedian would get a single item per night, assuming all comedians have double items (no one has said otherwise so far) and notty didn't wipe their items (which would obfuscate this and it makes me thing notty is even more mafia!)

 

[sessybessy]

I'm gonna vote HK, I think their claim is a bit of a mess despite saying I'd room with them I feel really uneasy about rooming now that I've thought about it, also HK just vibes mafia to me idk it's a gut feeling I guess ?. Idk if psychic is exactly town sided and Notty has a stronger claim than HK imo and I wanna see what will happen if Notty stays in the game for one more day before we lynch them too lol

vote HK

 

[Mooglie]

time to try and understand alishas logic

SITUATION 1 - TWO TOWN OPTIONS
A B C vote 1
D E F vote 2
*coinflip*
1A - 1 IS LYNCHED OH NO!
A B and C implicated - good job A was evil!
D E and F laugh at the foolish A B and C
1B - 2 IS LYNCHED OH NO!
D E and F implicated - good job F was evil!
A B and C laugh at the foolish D E and F

SITUATION 2 - ONE MAFIA, ONE TOWN
A B C vote 1
D E F vote 2
*coinflip*
2A - 1 IS LYNCHED WOOHOO!
D E and F implicated - good job F was evil
A B and C look innocent - but oh no A is mafia and looks innocent thats just how mafia plays out and if this wasn't a coinflip the same thing would have happened!
2B - 2 IS LYNCHED OH NO!
D E and F implicated - good job F was evil
A B and C look innocent - but oh no A is mafia and looks innocent thats just how mafia plays out and if this wasn't a coinflip the same thing would have happened!

SITUATION 3 - TWO MAFIA OPTIONS
A B C vote 1
D E F vote 2
wait a second theres not gonna be 4 mafia this game!
*coinflip anyway*
3A - 1 IS LYNCHED WOOHOO!
D E and F implicated - good job F was evil
A B and C look innocent - but oh no A is mafia and looks innocent thats just how mafia plays out and if this wasn't a coinflip the same thing would have happened!
3B - 2 IS LYNCHED WOOHOO!
A B and C implicated - good job A was evil
D E and F look innocent - but oh no F is mafia and looks innocent thats just how mafia plays out and if this wasn't a coinflip the same thing would have happened!

from what i can understand nothing would be different if it ended up being a non-coinflip to a coinflip in terms of scumhunting!

 

[hipmeow]

whats the reasoning behind the hk lynch again

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Votecount

Nottykitten - hipmeow, HKCaper, webpaige (3/5)
HKCaper - Nottykitten, Alisha, Mooglie, sessybessy (4/5)
Refuse - (0/5)

Deadline

 

[webpaige]

whats the reasoning behind the hk lynch again

because notty thinks mind powers bad, spirit powers good

 

[Nottykitten]

whats the reasoning behind the hk lynch again

Maybe you want someone else to answer this but they claim to be the town cop that can investigate whomever they want if they're alone in a room, or the person thats in the room with them if they are paired up. However they chose to go into a room last night where already 3 people claimed they would go into, essentially making them useless that night. Why would someone with that role go into a room where already 3 people are expected to go? They wouldn't and thats why I think this entire claim is fake.

Also mental powers are bad

 

[Alisha]

the implications are tainted if you think someone voted a certain way to cause a coinflip in the first place

 

[Alisha]

7 mins hnnnnnng

 

[webpaige]

vote HK

protecting notty at the last minute huh???

because notty thinks mind powers bad, spirit powers good

Also mental powers are bad

 

[Mooglie]

the implications are tainted if you think someone voted a certain way to cause a coinflip in the first place

but who did this out of all the people voting
and wouldnt you just throw suspicion on the person who caused this in your case
that person would be tim for unvoting (i guess????)

 

[Nottykitten]

7 mins hnnnnnng

Its not a coinflip anymore unless Tim decides he'd rather vote me