I mean it'd make Whistleblower out but massclaim, depending on how mafia do it, could be better for us
If most mafia claim citizen then we have decent odds
If most claim PR and 1-2 claim citizen then we have the worst odds
Republic - Completed
- Thread starter Prizyms
- Start date
If most mafia claim citizen then we have decent odds
If most claim PR and 1-2 claim citizen then we have the worst odds
Actually you were loving the mass claims and didn't want them to stop!
I worded that stupidly, and probably asked the wrong person.
I was just curious about this in general, but it might be best not to discuss our plan there.
I assume your night kill still goes through if you die.
Agreed, there's no way inf is town. After notty is dead, inf should be next.
also i think everyone is considering the target swap in the wrong place
consider this where the purple stars is the swap ira made & the purple lines are the consequences caused by it
i highly doubt that inf, as mafia, made a miraculous guess that ltin was the subversive since there was otherwise no way to guess it other than him being invidia (mafia rolecop) and investigating ltin given info from the dissenter in the court chat (notty) during evening chat
'but oog, inf being invidia didnt make sense if we considered ira's swap occuring at point C (rune -> hunter) since he was proven to target neither if aquas information was accurate - now he could be invidia and therefore be lying about targeting rune and actually investigated ltin!'
well i had a brief lapse in faith but then i realised why in the world would ira swap inf and whoever the guilty party is that killed hunter last night unless they were trying to make them look guilty on a tracking report - if inf was actually invidia, ira could have swapped inf and one of the dissenters that did nothing last night to make him look innocent and have an easy citizen claim at least
ALSO given that noone is reported to be poisoned this leaves two possibilities
a) inf, the actual subversive, blocked rune who was the mafia poisoner
b) ltin was gula (two vote mafia kill guy who can solo kill) and therefore two mafia had to sacrifice their night actions to carry out the mafia night kill - avaritia (the poisoner) and ??? probably superbia (mafia godfather)
i was initially thinking (b) but then it would make no sense as to why ira didnt swap inf and acedia (granny) BUT THEN i thought what if it was (a) and ltin was acedia, losing his granny abilities (confirmed by priz as being a possible situation rn) and therefore ira could not possibly swap inf and acedia and so had to swap them onto gula (carrying out the solo mafia night kill in this situation) AND that would make inf's subversive blocking report prove that rune is the mafia poisoner if noone claims to be poisoned (i guarantee a mafia is suddenly gonna come forward and lie about being poisoned rn)
i hope that makes sense
also why i think inf would be swapped onto a gula (in situation (a)) is that he raised a lot of controversy and would therefore be the target of many investigative night actions (aka aquas tracking or the monitor) and so they tried to frame him (aquas tracking returning as visiting the murdered player & monitor returning inf as mafia)
also i think notty is genuinely the revo
consider this where the purple stars is the swap ira made & the purple lines are the consequences caused by it
i highly doubt that inf, as mafia, made a miraculous guess that ltin was the subversive since there was otherwise no way to guess it other than him being invidia (mafia rolecop) and investigating ltin given info from the dissenter in the court chat (notty) during evening chat
'but oog, inf being invidia didnt make sense if we considered ira's swap occuring at point C (rune -> hunter) since he was proven to target neither if aquas information was accurate - now he could be invidia and therefore be lying about targeting rune and actually investigated ltin!'
well i had a brief lapse in faith but then i realised why in the world would ira swap inf and whoever the guilty party is that killed hunter last night unless they were trying to make them look guilty on a tracking report - if inf was actually invidia, ira could have swapped inf and one of the dissenters that did nothing last night to make him look innocent and have an easy citizen claim at least
ALSO given that noone is reported to be poisoned this leaves two possibilities
a) inf, the actual subversive, blocked rune who was the mafia poisoner
b) ltin was gula (two vote mafia kill guy who can solo kill) and therefore two mafia had to sacrifice their night actions to carry out the mafia night kill - avaritia (the poisoner) and ??? probably superbia (mafia godfather)
i was initially thinking (b) but then it would make no sense as to why ira didnt swap inf and acedia (granny) BUT THEN i thought what if it was (a) and ltin was acedia, losing his granny abilities (confirmed by priz as being a possible situation rn) and therefore ira could not possibly swap inf and acedia and so had to swap them onto gula (carrying out the solo mafia night kill in this situation) AND that would make inf's subversive blocking report prove that rune is the mafia poisoner if noone claims to be poisoned (i guarantee a mafia is suddenly gonna come forward and lie about being poisoned rn)
i hope that makes sense
also why i think inf would be swapped onto a gula (in situation (a)) is that he raised a lot of controversy and would therefore be the target of many investigative night actions (aka aquas tracking or the monitor) and so they tried to frame him (aquas tracking returning as visiting the murdered player & monitor returning inf as mafia)
also i think notty is genuinely the revo
ive read notty as not mafia this entire game and ADMITTEDLY ALL MY READS HAVE BEEN WRONG but theres like no way theyre town now after claiming revo also i totally read nottys posts from now on as this smug guy just sitting on their throne and having an evil smirk watching us and knowing that we dont really have an option other than to follow their command despite being a party opposite to us (i mean i havent considered anything about the consequences of town needing revo yet but ill look into that soon:tm:)
That's a legit concern. Only Hunter would have received litns role from the hearing, and he's dead. If possibilities of who the dictator might call a hearing on were discussed in the council chat then the mafia would have a pretty good idea of who to investigate that night and there is a good chance it wasn't luck dependent, but instead either a good read or flat out obvious.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
I think notty is mafia.
She played a high stakes game round 1, and won, with 3-4 townies dead.
She wanted to our our vigilante, ender, dead, and was bought that she was already a bit suspicious, and thought it wasn’t worth it to be even more suspicious by outing him.
Realizing she was now our prime target, she tries to keep being sensible, writing long posts and seem normal.
She still thinks she is gonna get killed off though.
She claims rev in a hope to not get lynched and create confusion.
They could've poisoned Velz, Caff or any other that hasn't spoken today
I think the chances are just too low.
If I understand correctly, he would actually have to be the role to get the info, as if it was someone else that was the investigation role, they would be unable to give inffy the information of Ltins role.
well I GUESS but they really shouldnt have poisoned anyone else in the council given that the revo wants to target potential dictators as well
but i guess caff is a concern but what are the odds!
Its a matter of time. One of the few useful roles remaining for us, so they're probably waiting until the last moment.
I don’t think notty is rev.
I do however think that we probably should keep rev alive for a bit.
This might be me understanding the game wrong, so if there is any flaws please point them out.
Rev needs 3 dictators to fall, to be one of the last 2/3 people alive, or to be elected dictator.
Rev does not want mafia to win.
This means that if we are going on a road to a straight lose, with mafia winning, rev should, and would most likely be trying to kill mafia.
Of course if we are doing good, it would be even worse for rev, but if we keep fucking up, and with democracy being slow if we chose that next, we might be in a really bad spot. Rev would, if I understand their role correctly, want to be scum hunting.
I do however think that we probably should keep rev alive for a bit.
This might be me understanding the game wrong, so if there is any flaws please point them out.
Rev needs 3 dictators to fall, to be one of the last 2/3 people alive, or to be elected dictator.
Rev does not want mafia to win.
This means that if we are going on a road to a straight lose, with mafia winning, rev should, and would most likely be trying to kill mafia.
Of course if we are doing good, it would be even worse for rev, but if we keep fucking up, and with democracy being slow if we chose that next, we might be in a really bad spot. Rev would, if I understand their role correctly, want to be scum hunting.