I guess it also is weird if caff is a Mafia pr since all the others seem to be vanilla (which is another thing I'm confused on - why were town given such an OP inn if all the Mafia were only vanilla?
We don't know that all the Mafia are vanilla.
In fact they probably arent.
I'm still certain that the only reason they've shown up as "vanilla" (they technically haven't) is because their roles/ability explanations haven't been given to us. This is most likely being caused by another role e.g.
the gravedigger or
janitor except it applies to all the Mafia until said person dies instead of just acting on a single person or day.
That or the Mafia just intrinsically don't get their roles revealed to help them out as one of their group's natural abilities.
It wouldn't make much sense otherwise.
I also don't necessarily doubt there being 3 employees with the current 2 claimers actually having that ability (as some of this game seems to follow that rule of 3 with the Security inn and the Board of Directors) but at the same time I don't entirely believe there'd be so many roles that send messages, but that's just me.
Our list of claims so far:
1. Dessern5 - Body Double; visited Ooglie night 1
2. CaffeinatedKitty - Employee
3. Wimali - Tracker, part of Security Inn
4. Timdood3 - Will claim tomorrow; apart of BoD; innocent by cop report
5. Samlen - Terrorist
6. Jkangaroo - Cop, part of Security Inn
7. Ooglie101 - ?
8. Oak63
9. Nottykitten - Doctor claim; visited JK night 2
10. Mulbery - Terrorist
11. Infected_alien8_ - Corrupt Official (supposedly allied to Oak)
12. Vatumok - Employee (sent messages)
13. Marskid - Vig, part of Security Inn
14. hipman500 - Employee
15. webpaige - Terrorist
There are still 2 killing roles out there (most likely third-party and a remaining Mafia)
We can basically confirm Notty and Dess aren't killing roles(at least, third-party anyways) based on the watcher/tracker investigations, although it might help if we know what both of your other actions were.
Tim and Ooglie are still unknowns, although unless there's a "Godfather"-esq role or the janitoring that we've seen so far from the terrorists deaths cross over to investigations as well (doubtful) then we can generally trust tim... but that leaves Ooglie.
Then there's our 2 Employee claims which we are uncertain of, though Tim can at least confirm Caff sent him a message, which is something.
And then there's infected who we already know is third-party, but has lied about his role before so we can't necessarily trust his explanations now.
Unless more comes up, I think our best bet would be to lynch Ooglie, one of our "employees" or if we want to wait a bit, go for the safe bet(and one we will have to do eventually) and lynch Infected.