You townread fantome but now you're gonna be open with a policy lynch?
Yes I know the definiton of a policy lynch but combined with your insistence on not lynching on day 0 you're coming across very strange now.
And policy lynches almost always hurt town
I think it's a secondary answer to my "If you had to kill someone question"
Like "If I had to kill someone, I'd kill whoever, but I'd also consider killing fantome for policy reasons"
If I had to kill one person today, it would have to be Alisha. Something about her flip-floppiness gives me a Mafia vibe.
You're also defining my natural change in opinions as flip-flops, where that says I'm taking stances completely the opposite of my original stance.
I have not done that, I've shifted my lynch preferences as the game goes on just like anyone else, it's a mischaracterization to call that flip-flopping.
I have not done that, I've shifted my lynch preferences as the game goes on just like anyone else, it's a mischaracterization to call that flip-flopping.
When you accuse around half the cast being scum, and shift your preferences that much, in my eyes it's illogical for a townsperson to do that. I feel you're a little too bloodthirsty.
However, with that said, TWG has also appeared scum in my eyes with the policy Lynch.
On day 0, with literally no information besides everybody's behaviors, there's going to be flipflopping. I'm willing to give benefit of the doubt there.
Hopefully WITH concrete information next day I can contribute more, but right now I am hella lost without something to latch on to.
I'm gonna guess policy-lynch is bad because it wastes a lynch, has no backing evidence to it (and therefore doesn't provide information based on people's opinions), and probably scum wouldn't bring that much attention to themselves in the first place?
...Nah I'm still iffy about Fantome. Yeah, a plain policy lynch is bad, but there's still the earlier debate to go by. I still think there's something to be gained there, as uninformed as that opinion might be. Or I'm lazy and latching on to my first real suspicions of the thread because I literally can't come up with anything else.
I'm just not suspicious enough of anybody else to lynch them over Fantome.
Hopefully WITH concrete information next day I can contribute more, but right now I am hella lost without something to latch on to.
Ah jeez, um. Alright. I don't really have any explicit reads on anyone...
I'm gonna guess policy-lynch is bad because it wastes a lynch, has no backing evidence to it (and therefore doesn't provide information based on people's opinions), and probably scum wouldn't bring that much attention to themselves in the first place?
...Nah I'm still iffy about Fantome. Yeah, a plain policy lynch is bad, but there's still the earlier debate to go by. I still think there's something to be gained there, as uninformed as that opinion might be. Or I'm lazy and latching on to my first real suspicions of the thread because I literally can't come up with anything else.
I'm just not suspicious enough of anybody else to lynch them over Fantome.
I just felt that the whole paragraph seems quite like defensive of Ernie but also the idea of him throwing in that there is no reason to vote Ernie, although we agreed that lynching a potentially less active player would be more beneficial at this stage of the game. And then the last sentence was very definitive like a "fuck everybody else's opinions i'm not joining the vote".
Yet when a little more pressure was put on Ernie he started to voice the opinion of voting for him. Which I feel was very strange, perhaps a tactic to seem more town? IDK its kinda vibes, but due to what has been said.
Whoever who bought up policy-lynching Fantome at this point is starting to very look a bit scum in my opinion. Seems to be a convenient sort of "let's just use his demeanour to get rid of him" free pass kind of thing.
Meanwhile I'll actually give a re-updated version of my reads:
Positive
1. Fog - still my strongest Town read. If he weren't Town I'd be really really really surprised.
2. Infected_alien8 - no change in read here.
Neutral positive
1. Okx - same read as before.
2. MoltenAshes (Wyatt) - same read as before.
3. Shadow_Hunter3 - same read as before.
4. Timdood3 - right so I'm going to move this read down here below Shadow's simply because after I pointed out regarding an Ernie lynch + what Fog said he seemed to be a bit more agreeable all of a sudden though I think I can explain this behaviour, though I'm being wary.
Neutral
1. Alisha - no change from before. I'm inclined to shift this read up eventually.
2. Fantome (Les) - the way how Les has been acting in general is just too Les even. I feel like he still could be SK but his behaviour in the later part of this day is making me shift his read up, and even if he was an SK (let's not assume there's one to begin with or otherwise though) he would be free to scumhunt and the reads would be valuable.
3. TheWeakGuy48_ (Jobbiis) - his somewhat scummy posts from before is dead weird but my vibes are just telling me he's Town. Mostly get this vibe that if he were Mafia he'd be more inclined to side with opinions and not do the reverse. Like personally I feel like he wouldn't be so open about unpopular opinions if he were scum. The only thing which really strikes me with Weak here is that post from before regarding villagers being exposed.
4. Unusual_dude - not too much change here either, but if I were to assume that Weak is Town then I'd be more likely to think that Unu is Town too.
5. catgirl12466 - no change in read.
Neutral negative
None
Negative
1. Ernie138 - his behaviour as I have highlighted in previous posts.
I still think lynching Ernie would be the best option if we have to lynch someone even though if people don't necessarily agree as he is mainly inactive and it would be harmful to us later in the game, not to mention the scumread I just have on him.
Either way with how the votes are headed I can bet that this day will end in a no-lynch because reaching majority is simply a difficult task. If possible I'd still like to vote somebody at least.
Meanwhile I'll actually give a re-updated version of my reads:
Positive
1. Fog - still my strongest Town read. If he weren't Town I'd be really really really surprised.
2. Infected_alien8 - no change in read here.
Neutral positive
1. Okx - same read as before.
2. MoltenAshes (Wyatt) - same read as before.
3. Shadow_Hunter3 - same read as before.
4. Timdood3 - right so I'm going to move this read down here below Shadow's simply because after I pointed out regarding an Ernie lynch + what Fog said he seemed to be a bit more agreeable all of a sudden though I think I can explain this behaviour, though I'm being wary.
Neutral
1. Alisha - no change from before. I'm inclined to shift this read up eventually.
2. Fantome (Les) - the way how Les has been acting in general is just too Les even. I feel like he still could be SK but his behaviour in the later part of this day is making me shift his read up, and even if he was an SK (let's not assume there's one to begin with or otherwise though) he would be free to scumhunt and the reads would be valuable.
3. TheWeakGuy48_ (Jobbiis) - his somewhat scummy posts from before is dead weird but my vibes are just telling me he's Town. Mostly get this vibe that if he were Mafia he'd be more inclined to side with opinions and not do the reverse. Like personally I feel like he wouldn't be so open about unpopular opinions if he were scum. The only thing which really strikes me with Weak here is that post from before regarding villagers being exposed.
4. Unusual_dude - not too much change here either, but if I were to assume that Weak is Town then I'd be more likely to think that Unu is Town too.
5. catgirl12466 - no change in read.
Neutral negative
None
Negative
1. Ernie138 - his behaviour as I have highlighted in previous posts.
I still think lynching Ernie would be the best option if we have to lynch someone even though if people don't necessarily agree as he is mainly inactive and it would be harmful to us later in the game, not to mention the scumread I just have on him.
Either way with how the votes are headed I can bet that this day will end in a no-lynch because reaching majority is simply a difficult task. If possible I'd still like to vote somebody at least.