Mafia: Saints & Sinners - GAME OVER MAFIA WIN

[Aqua]

why?

cus she's the devil

 

[Alisha]

why?

because reasons i cannot say yet, but i think sinners who ID themselves are inherrently more trustworthy than they would be otherwise.

 

[Aqua]

because reasons i cannot say yet, but i think sinners who ID themselves are inherrently more trustworthy than they would be otherwise.

Admit that you just want to have a big sinner orgy with the devil

 

[Alisha]

Admit that you just want to have a big sinner orgy with the devil

i want to know who might be capable of taking part in the sinner orgy with the devil

 

[Aqua]

i want to know who might be capable of taking part in the sinner orgy with the devil

gasp u slut

 

[Aqua]

For real tho Alisha do you not think it's would be wiser to wait until we know more about the game before getting all sinners to claim?

Further what're your thoughts on a lynch upon yourself or Tim, do you have any defence for either of you?

 

[Timdood3]

The reason why I think further sinners shouldn't claim is because I think it's this game's equivalent of VT and would narrow the pool of NK targets.

 

[Aqua]

The reason why I think further sinners shouldn't claim is because I think it's this game's equivalent of VT and would narrow the pool of NK targets.

So why did you claim?

 

[Alisha]

For real tho Alisha do you not think it's would be wiser to wait until we know more about the game before getting all sinners to claim?

Further what're your thoughts on a lynch upon yourself or Tim, do you have any defence for either of you?

honestly i felt like i knew enough to make an educated guess as to what could potentially go down and wanted to jump in with claiming and see who would join me, and from tim's reaction i think i made a correct guess

i already got tim to go down the abyss with me which is good

i'd rather not be lynched and i'll explain the details of my big brain play once more people respond, I have no defense for my actions beyond what I've already implied. Tim I townread as of now.

 

[Alisha]

and hey if the big brain play doesn't pan out it still got people talking and was a lot of fun! but it's going to pan out, just watch!

 

[Timdood3]

So why did you claim?

Because I hadn't yet considered that possibility; I was overly hasty, emboldened by Alisha's confidence.

 

[Aqua]

i'd rather not be lynched and i'll explain the details of my big brain play once more people respond, I have no defense for my actions beyond what I've already implied. Tim I townread as of now.

What benefits would come from not explaining your big brain play before people claim?

 

[Alisha]

The reason why I think further sinners shouldn't claim is because I think it's this game's equivalent of VT and would narrow the pool of NK targets.

i think that's a point in favor of having sinners claim if anything

 

[Timdood3]

i think that's a point in favor of having sinners claim if anything

????

 

[Alisha]

What benefits would come from not explaining your big brain play before people claim?

see: timdood's reaction to outing himself

 

[Aqua]

Because I hadn't yet considered that possibility; I was overly hasty, emboldened by Alisha's confidence.

Well then I guess you should feel pride that I believe you have the critical thinking skills of someone over the age of 4.

I don't buy it.

 

[Alisha]

????

who says a VT stays a VT the entire game?

 

[Aqua]

see: timdood's reaction to outing himself

But you believe Tim is innocent because he claimed? Despite the fact that it's now potentially gonna lead to his lynch? Surely that's more harmful for town than the alternative?

 

[Alisha]

But you believe Tim is innocent because he claimed? Despite the fact that it's now potentially gonna lead to his lynch? Surely that's more harmful for town than the alternative?

it's not harmful in the long term

 

[Timdood3]

who says a VT stays a VT the entire game?

Says I don't buy into the alignment shifting aspect.
Unless I was mistaken and our roles aren't as similar as I thought.

 

[Aqua]

it's not harmful in the long term

potentially but take me, a townie, maybe a sinner maybe I'm not. How would you expect me to be convinced by your enthusiasm alone? Like Tim I believe I too have the critical thinking skills of a person over the age of 4, why should I trust you and run the risk of throwing the game?

 

[Alisha]

potentially but take me, a townie, maybe a sinner maybe I'm not. How would you expect me to be convinced by your enthusiasm alone? Like Tim I believe I too have the critical thinking skills of a person over the age of 4, why should I trust you and run the risk of throwing the game?

what scenario is a sinner claiming throwing the game?

hey my enthusiasm convinced one person so already the plan is a partial success!

 

[Aqua]

what scenario is a sinner claiming throwing the game?

Any scenario that involves the mafia winning/gaining a considerable advantage by targeting sinners.

hey my enthusiasm convinced one person so already the plan is a partial success!

Yeah but they're clearly scum so that doesn't count

Ok so let's assume you are a sinner why don't you elaborate what that entails, what does your role say about Deals with the devil etc.?

Timdood3 answer too but at a reasonable time, I don't want you copying alisha's answers

 

[Timdood3]

Ok so let's assume you are a sinner why don't you elaborate what that entails, what does your role say about Deals with the devil etc.?

@Timdood3 answer too but at a reasonable time, I don't want you copying alisha's answers

Does that mean you want me to answer first?

 

[Alisha]

Any scenario that involves the mafia winning/gaining a considerable advantage by targeting sinners.

Considering how cagey I've been I accept this answer even though I don't believe they do

Yeah but they're clearly scum so that doesn't count

That's exactly why this plan is working! (Even if I don't agree that he's scum, yet)

Ok so let's assume you are a sinner why don't you elaborate what that entails, what does your role say about Deals with the devil etc.?

Making a deal with the devil involves gaining an ability, but may have unexpected consequences. Deals are made by declaring them in the main thread.