Republic - Completed
- Thread starter Prizyms
- Start date
I claimed citizen a while ago
Flexibility isn't bad and I think that reasoning that I am mafia is way out of line.
If autocracy, definitely don't me because we need all uncc'd townies to be elected
I see the benefits of autocracy, but right now I just don't feel safe switching to autocracy unless the rev is dead. I think we're basically fucked if the rev is still alive and snipes our second dictator(which would definitely happen)
It's very cocky to claim you "proved me wrong", nor did I bandwagon onto you. I gave reasoning, don't call it bandwagoning, I am sure there were many others who literally just voted you without an explanation cause they saw others voting for you.
It's not like your plan of autocracy went well for town at all. I wanted to do democracy first because we only have a limited number of autocracies, and I didn't want to zip through them unless we needed them. What if our suspicious council members all died in the night? What were we supposed to do, lynch one of our uncc'd townies? No, that's when we would switch to autocracy.
Flexibility isn't bad and I think that reasoning that I am mafia is way out of line.
Are you voting for democracy or autocracy? If democracy, why are you voting for me? What is your reasoning?
If autocracy, definitely don't me because we need all uncc'd townies to be elected
I see the benefits of autocracy, but right now I just don't feel safe switching to autocracy unless the rev is dead. I think we're basically fucked if the rev is still alive and snipes our second dictator(which would definitely happen)
Also for what it's worth I think rune is godfather, just seems way too sure that he would appear as a townie and I don't read third party off him. Will vote on council members later
You gave reasoning after I had to ask you twice, yes. At first it was just a vote, then I asked why, then you said "you're suspicious", then I asked why, then you came up with your 'reason'
Regardless of the outcome, I'm talking about the reasons for supporting it or not. You completely ignored all the stats Notty provided which, yes she was Mafia, were still completely valid. Your reasons are fair enough if you ignore the fact that without our dictator kill we'd likely lose because the revo would keep aiming for our dictator (town) each time so we needed the dictator to kill as well. You never brought this up before so it couldn't have been your reason.
The fact you went against Notty does make you sliiightly more credible but you could easily have done that just to look innocent in case she died.
what i was thinking at the time was i'd rather elect people i trust since i'm now leaning more towards autocracy and even though you claimed citizen you were the among the first few that came to mind
Oh well I appreciate it but it's still better as a baseline to only have the uncc'd, that way even if I was hypothetically dictator then dissenters couldn't try to convince town I was a dissenter and get my overthrown
I mean, a lot of people "ignored" it, that's why the original day 1 votes were based around democracy. Why am I getting singled out? I'm pretty sure those stats got questioned and disproven by Hunter and Aqua as well. I think I gave my own thoughts on Notty's stats, I don't remember if I typed this out or just thought it, but I will admit I didn't look too hard at them because I didn't fully believe them. I didn't believe that the game was set up in a way that we absolutely needed to switch to autocracy immediately. Like I said, I felt from the beginning that flexibility in switching from democracy to autocracy was powerful, and I didn't want to waste one of our dictatorships before we needed it
I think you're tunnel visioning on the whole "autocracy is better" thing. You really can't state that notty's plan was town-favorable, it's notty and she's a really good player. It certainly isn't favorable for us right now and we followed her plan pretty concisely
considering notty turned out to be mafia the idea that notty's plan was actually favourable to mafia in some way is not out of the question
n1: hunter
i didnt understand my role and thought that if i watched someone who died only their killers name would be removed but no if they die the whole report is scrapped so NO REPORT
n2: roob
i assumed notty (still thought they were rev) would kill me/inf, mafia would kill ender and poison roob but turns out rev killed roob, mafia killed aqua and poisoned ender so again NO REPORT
inb4 wow you're so much more untrustworthy now you have no information!!
Just because it went wrong because the choices people made (electing 3 uncc rather than 5 and killing ltin/caff) were unfortunate, doesn't make it any less town-favourable
We can read the setup and see for ourselves that it was
My point is you seem really insistent that Notty, whose entire role is based around the town losing, gave us a plan that is absolutely, 100% non-negotiable best for town.
Do you really not think there might be some deception there? Do you really think this game is so simple there is one "best" way to play?
Tbh this is fair enough
My point about your reason for suspecting me still stands
Yes you could just have tunnel-visioned me as a townie but I'm not sure I buy it
she said she was going to hide endy's role for his safety evening 1 and revealed it pretty quickly on day 2
she said she was going to kill twg evening 2 and it was revealed that she killed roob, an uncounterclaimed town power role on day 3
i thought i escaped having to deal with notty's lies when we executed her
