probably because I had*I'm really not sure how to respond to this, because I probably had similar situations in the past.
Grammar is not my strong-suit.
probably because I had*I'm really not sure how to respond to this, because I probably had similar situations in the past.
Your reason for doing something can't change after the fact.Well I was bandwagoning to be fairly honest. But the more I thought of it, the more suspicious road became but then people began targeting me for voting for road so I changed it to a joke.
To be honest I'm not entirely sure why it's an issue.
I'd give Geekenstein the benefit of the doubt they are just confused and worried about this, although Notme did vote for The Road To Ruin in the first place, so it wasn't like Geekenstein was the first person to suggest lynching them. The Road To Ruin vote was the first reason people started being suspicious of Geek?Could be a carefully playing townie but right now you are more suspicious than Geek in my opinion. I want to hear some opinions from Runemen4 and Mulbery and superhalo6 on who they consider suspicious as they haven't done much all game.
that's pretty rich coming from someone who's never played a mafia game before opposed to tim who has played the majority of mafia games in the communityCan we grow up and actually play a mafia game
Well this is how the game is played, the fact you keep reacting like this can also imply you're upset you might get lynched because you got a good role.I honestly am sick and tired of this. Can we grow up and actually play a mafia game without falling over a good luck noye to the towb or a bandwagon vote.
Is that too much to ask guys?
Have fun, most important part!
I think this was a big mistake, you felt like Vat was seriously accusing you so you came up with the first reasoning you could think of to try and explain your voting while I don't think you actually had reasoning besides joke voting. Phrasing here matters, because saying "even if they are innocent" implies that you'd lynch even a proven innocent player for saying this. I doubt this is what you meant but I read it like that for sure.Well their post seemed a bit suspicious how they asked if you could kill people at night. It's a perfectly alright reason to lynch someone even if they are innocent.
Your first mistake here was giving no reasoning as to why you were voting Road. I've made plenty of votes in my life without reasoning, but if you do you can 100% expect people are going to find it suspicious you didn't give a reason and are going to ask you for that reasoning. And it's just better in general to give a reasoning so people can understand what you're doing.Gonna place my vote on Road To Ruin
Unvote
vote Road To Ruin
Question:
If somebody dies do their ranks get revealed to us after they die or is it secretive until the game is over?
This is a very Mafia thing to do, especially when it was litterally one bad accusation. The Mafia's goal is to try and not get lynched. Most of the time Mafia doesn't want to stand out and be in the crossfire, and thus try to blend in with the town. You're trying waay too hard to try and fit in with everyone else and not be accused of anything. If someone says they think you're too keen on not lynching someone, either explain to them why you think he's viewing it wrong and why you're not too keen, explain why you don't want to lynch someone or simply don't respond at all if the accusation is bad and not really anything serious.So you basically said it to try and save your skin?
Mafia is as fun as you make it be. If you choose to be salty about people thinking you're Mafia(I've had this myself a few times), you're not going to have much fun since this is bound to happen sooner or later. I for one enjoy making posts(even gigantic ones like this one), and enjoy arguments either for or against me and searching for Mafia. Mafia is a game where arguing is a given. At one point in the game people are going to accuse you of something because of things you said/did. If it's a serious accusation like the one against you at the moment where people accuse you of changing stories. It's your job as Town to speak clearly and try to explain yourself well for the better of the town. As Mafia/Third Party, you have a similar job but mostly you do it to not get lynched and lose the game.Lynch me if you wish :)
I just wanted to actually enjoy a mafia game, suddenly a rule of ER is No Fun whatsoever.
This. That's what the Good Luck thing implied to us. But it isn't even so much about the first part of this quote than it is about the second. Almost all your posts on day 1 have been appealing to emotion not giving any arguments on why you shouldn't be lynched. If you're confused what people are accusing you of again, read back or simply tell them you're a bit confused and ask again.The implication that the town would fail miserably without her. And the fact that it's an appeal to emotion in a game of logic.
First, Tim wasn't being annoying he was simply discussing the current situation and evidence. Second, in a game of mafia you should ALWAYS read arguments. Especially if they're against you. I get that you get confused about why you're being accused if you don't read every post. And third, there is nothing wrong with saying good luck, that isn't what theyre saying. They're saying that you have given up, and appealed to emotion instead of trying to defend yourself. Then came the next three quotes:You are passing the line of annoying by a long while.
I didn't read your arguments because that was uncalled for.
Wtf is wrong with saying Good Luck to people?
No I won't explain until my question had been answered.
Why the hell am I being targeted so much?
I thought this was going to be a fun game but clearly people don't know how to have fun.
And I'm sure I explained why I changed my vote.
This isn't helping anything. All I see is passive-agressiveness and still no explaination. If everyone is asking you for an explaination, even if you think you've given one either say it again or link them to your explaination. Saying "I already explained" isn't helping anyone because clearly people think you haven't. And last, you threaten Oog that he should be thankful you didn't vote him. Threatening in Mafia is a very scummy thing to do. These posts, along with the ones after are all short-posts where you refuse to coöperate with the Town and that is not helping your case at all. In the end you finally made the post we all wanted to hear and said:Am I not allowed to change a vote?
You should be thankful I didn't vote for you.
This is either what we wanted to hear since Inf asked on day 0, or something pretty close to it. Since now we know better why you did what you did. The reason it's an issue is because you lied to the town by claiming one thing and then later claiming another. Take it as a general rule that as a Town you should not lie. It doesn't help the Town at all but only hurts them.Well I was bandwagoning to be fairly honest. But the more I thought of it, the more suspicious road became but then people began targeting me for voting for road so I changed it to a joke.
To be honest I'm not entirely sure why it's an issue.
I am convinced that Geek chose to use the word "Ranks" instead of "Roles", because in her Mafia Role PM it explains to her the Mafia Rank Hierarchy. Since the Leader has the highest rank, then the Leiutenant is the second rank. Third rank is either Scout/Propagandist and the lowest rank is the Soldier. I am convinced this is why she chose the word Rank, since she is in one of them.Question:
If somebody dies do their ranks get revealed to us after they die or is it secretive until the game is over?
So give away the fact you're town and now every mafia will either lynch you or kill you during night?Well I said it.
There is literally one role that isn't town other than mafia roles.So give away the fact you're town and now every mafia will either lynch you or kill you during night?
I threw the game because at this time I don't care. I've given all of my defense and now I'm throwing myself into the mafia so they can kill me.At what point does this become game throwing?