It just hit me tonight when I was catching up on the three new map submissions that were just submitted once the forums went up.
I feel like we should have some sort of a voting/rating system for the maps that are being submitted + those that are already accepted. Based on this I have come up with the following ideas:
1:
Maps that are being submitted get voted on weekly, X amount of +1's and the map is submitted, X amount of -1's and the map is declined.
2:
A map review/rating sub-category that would contain a thread for each individual map where the map could be rated based on aspects of gameplay (running, hiding), aesthetics(theme,continuity,quality), and possibly other things that I am too tired to think of at this very second.
3:
Map voting system like the one previously stated, except maps are just voted on until they reach the amount of +1s and -1s that are needed for a submission or for a denial. Along with this voting system would come a rating system right away in which people could rate the map based on what they think from the users post and exploring the .lvl file. This would not be as quality though as a review system for maps that have already been submitted because then the gameplay and other multiplayer factors within the map could be rated.
I ABSOLUTELY LOVE constructive criticism, so please, criticize.
I feel like we should have some sort of a voting/rating system for the maps that are being submitted + those that are already accepted. Based on this I have come up with the following ideas:
1:
Maps that are being submitted get voted on weekly, X amount of +1's and the map is submitted, X amount of -1's and the map is declined.
2:
A map review/rating sub-category that would contain a thread for each individual map where the map could be rated based on aspects of gameplay (running, hiding), aesthetics(theme,continuity,quality), and possibly other things that I am too tired to think of at this very second.
3:
Map voting system like the one previously stated, except maps are just voted on until they reach the amount of +1s and -1s that are needed for a submission or for a denial. Along with this voting system would come a rating system right away in which people could rate the map based on what they think from the users post and exploring the .lvl file. This would not be as quality though as a review system for maps that have already been submitted because then the gameplay and other multiplayer factors within the map could be rated.
I ABSOLUTELY LOVE constructive criticism, so please, criticize.
