as if you're not confident*but now you're saying you're not voting her since you think both roles could exist as if you're not certain
Like, I can believe a scenario where you think she could be scum but also could be town so you refrain from voting, but the way you presented your case against notty reads to me like you're confident she's mafia and don't really give consideration to her being town, which doesn't match with you then saying 'well I'm not voting her since I think our roles could both coexist', I'd have thought you'd find her likely enough to be mafia to outweigh that possibility and vote for her