It would be good because I'd have absolutely no suspicion on me and so it would be easy for me to do the kill. No-one would suspect anything.
No, me "picking" only townies does not make me suspicious. If I were a mafia, I'd be conscious of making myself stand out or making myself suspicious which would mean I wouldn't only pick townies.
Except, you needed a role to claim and a way to claim it. For obvious reasons claiming to be vanilla townie in a game full of power roles doesn't seem to fly easily.
Not necessarily because:
a) I wanted to die so we wouldn't have this situation today
b) I wasn't sure which of you was mafia. I thought it was more likely that you were, hence why I sent the message to you.
okay, so let's say you were townie and still a little on the fence about which of us was mafia. Well, if unu was mafia you could've sent the message to me to show that you at least used your night action. On the other hand, if from your perspective if you thought I was mafia you'd send the message to unu. There's no reason to send a message to someone who's likely to deny receiving it.
But you're the only one who thinks you could only do one at a time. I could easily have sent a message to unu while simultaneously killing dess, how would that prove me?
not sure why this isn't obvious. This is the standard in pretty much any game I've played and at the very least it's the current meta. There's no reason to assume the mechanics work different as a default. SURE THEY COULD BE DIFFERENT, but unusual could also secretly be a cop, or TWG could actually be a godfather vampire or something crazy like that. there are lots of things that could be different at any point in a mafia, but it only makes sense to run on some basic reasonable assumptions. So it just makes sense one would take int consideration how the mechanics probably works when deciding to use their night action. So, no it doesn't make sense that you'd be able to send a message to unu while killing dess.
Last night I tried to get myusername to kill me instead of someone else by acting like I had secret info on him and would persuade the town to vote for him tomorrow with the information that I had. That obviously didn't work.
perhaps I did exaggerate it a bit, but this post looks an awful lot like you were trying to say that in your actions last night you were operating under the assumption I am mafia. (Though, I know this is bullshit since you're mafia and the message is a lie.
Also on that note of not making a scene and bringing attention to myself, why the fuck would I have been in loggerheads with Danni (an un-cced cop) for ages as the only mafia left. It's counter intuitive and doesn't make a lot of sense. In hindsight, it was a stupid thing for a town to do, but it would be near suicide as a mafia.
I also would've turned my attention to unu and myusername, which I did not. Why would I have tried to stick out like a sore thumb????
And before you say that I wanted to change the town's opinion to think that TWG and Danni were mafia, when I was a mafia, what the fuck would the end goal be? If either of them had gotten lynched and subsequently flipped town, I'd be fucked.
A better tactic as a mafia in a situation like that is to just lay low and not attract attention, exactly like what myuser was doing and judging by the list, what the majority of the other mafias were doing as well.
Having the cop around in day 5 with 2 confirmed innocents is a very bad place to be as a lone mafia. When you add in the fact that I'm a watcher and would've seen you trying to kill him it's not unlikely that we could've ended up with 2 confirmed innocents(since you'd kill from the confirmed innocents pool and not the , danni still around as a cop, and only 5 people still alive. with ender being confirmed as the fool that makes it you vs unu or you vs me in a day with 5 people. That would've given us an automatic win since we would have enough mislynches to lynch both. alternatively, let's say you killed danni at night. Again we wake up with 5 people, but in that case I saw you kill Danni. Effectively that means that in a day with 5 people it'd be your claim vs mine. Again, we'd have enough mislynches and that it's an auto win for us.
lynching danni during the day was almost suicide for you as an option, but it's one of the best chances you had at the time to win because most other options ended in an auto win for the town.
By lynching ender we practically gave up an autowin for the town. furthermore, even if there'd been 2 mafia left (from my point of view I'd know that's you and unu) then it'd be a 2/3 chance for the town to lynch correctly and end up in an auto win the next day.
