Plane Troubles [Concluded]
- Thread starter Alisha
- Start date
- Status
Forgot to mention. Since you two voted for Swate and I'm pretty sure that mafia wouldn't do that even if they were desperate, I'm going to take back what I said and put a little faith in pikmon and Samlen... I need to start thinking before I post, don't I...
Waitwaitwait. Look how Samlen defended my other suspicion? Yeah, I don't think so. I won't vote quite yet, it would be(IMO) kinda foolish to do so this early, but I'm going to keep my eye on them.
I notice how you point out me being doctor after I essentially say I am. I mean, what are the odds that midnight guessed correctly twice unless she's unbelievably lucky? I'm sorry, I can't believe you. Not to mention, waiting until after she is correct twice to then counter claim doesn't make any sense to me. I'm still gonna say you and Mad, but I'm gonna wait still.
Either way, if (before your initial post):
Midnight was Cop
Caff was Town
Samlen (assumably) was Mafia
Mad (is assumably) was Mafia
Pikmon2 was ???? (at the time)
Only you, mad, and midnight could know who I was, but only you and (I should say assumably) mad would know 100% that I amdoctor by process of elimination. If you said this yesterday (in game), this might be a different story, but I choose not to believe you currently.
I didn't know you were doctor until I investigated you tonight, so I couldn't have done so otherwise. If I tried to counterclaim midnight's copclaim yesterday, I would only have my investigation of Swate and Sephhh to back me up, which everyone knew whom they were then anyways. Midnight had guessed that Kitty was innocent, and therfore had someone alive whom could back up her evidence. Whether this is because Kitty is also Mafia and knew about this plan or if mightnight just chose one of the few innocent people left, I don't know, but I can only try and persuade you to see the truth of my claim.
The fact you happened to investigate the two people that died is a bit suspcious, given, at least my opinion, Sephhh wasn't suspicious at all. Swate yes, but not Sephhh. And why not midnight instead of me? Why not bring any of this up yesterday? If you are cop, you kind of dug yourself in a hole by not saying anything yesterday, since the three people you identifed are: dead, or by process of elimination found out.
I investigated sephhh first night because nobody was suspicious since the first day went by so quickly. I didn't investigate midnight since I had concluded (logically) that she was Mafia. Since I figured I knew midnight was Mafia, I wanted to find the second Mafia member as fast as possible, in case I died soon. Maybe I had flawed logic along the lines somewhere here, but I did what I did. As for investigating you, no one had put hardly any suspicion on you at all, which made me wonder if you were a well hidden Mafia member. I also knew that whether you were Mafia or townsided, I could investigate one last time tonight to know for sure whom is the last Mafia member, while getting rid of one of the last Mafia members tonight.
Yeah, your logic was a bit flawed. How did you automatically conclude that Mid is mafia if there are still four townspeople? If she isn't cop, then she could also be town, and that's IF people believe that you are the real cop. I, for one, don't believe you at all.
Not necessarily. If another person was suspicious of your own suspicion, wouldn't that cement it in your mind and make you more confident about it? It's risky but makes it a possibility.
If she claimed she wascop she could've pinned on me or another town member which would have been much more effective, since mafia would win. Delaying it and putting everything at risk for mafia doesn't make much sense to me.
I'll hold off from voting a bit more to see what happens.
I was about to say that that wouldn't work, but then I realized it would. It was basically a "lynch wrong and lose" day(a MyLo, is it?) and mafia would have won had she claimed that someone innocent was mafia. So yeah, I think Mid really is the cop, and I'm not at all inclined to believe her counterclaim.
If she had tried to do that, the cop (me) would certainly have disclaimed her claim. This way she has more faith/support from you guys. The more I look at what I did, the more I realize that I really should have claimed earlier =S
- Status