Question is, who do we lynch?
I personally, don't want to risk anyone else dying. Notty was killed and he was one of the most pivotal roles.
If Mafia decides to kill someone, we only lose one and not two if we lynch.
Mafia Lite 3
- Thread starter Prizyms
- Start date
- Status
I personally, don't want to risk anyone else dying. Notty was killed and he was one of the most pivotal roles.
If Mafia decides to kill someone, we only lose one and not two if we lynch.
We could go for a no-lynch, but that might not be optimal. The thing is, it might or might not be worth a shot lynching someone in hope of getting a Mafia... not an easy judgement call to make between all of us.
No-lynching really will only lead to another town player getting eliminated, with the small chance of Janitor being killed.
We should lynch those who speak the least. The people who speak the most will be most valuable later on.
We should lynch those who speak the least. The people who speak the most will be most valuable later on.
Though I agree with you about eliminating at least someone. I'd have to disagree with lynching the "quietest", how are we even going to determine someone as quiet or less quiet than another? It is an easy solution to get action in our day event, but it might be a tactic of some town power roles to remain silent! Even though I am already accused of, I can promise this time that I am just a regular villager (or miller, seeing that I wouldn't know...), but my best guess is that no one will believe me anyways, which is understandable!
Maybe this sounds like a bad solution of mine, but I think it is the most appropiate thing to do to lynch a person that is "close" with Nottycat (friends, colleagues, etc.). As you know that such person(s) would know the most why to murder Nottycat at the very start.
Thats how it works on paper but if we decide to not lynch than where are we tommorow? Our best weapon is conflict, I notice alot the mafia tries to either remain on the sidelines or abstain where possible. If start making it a game where we all have to accuse Someone than the odds go up that one or two mafia members will slip up.
There are two types of players. Aggressive and passive. JKangaroo or Marnixxie, for example, is much more aggressive. They're going to be the types that help lead the game, scumhunt, and take sides.
Passive players are going to be the ones that usually abstain and want to wait til the next day to figure something out, and don't want to take the risk of pointing fingers. As well, they'll most likely sheep other players who seem to know what they are talking about rather than forming their own hard opinion.
The behaviors of both types carry through being mafia, so both quiet and talkative players are likely to be Mafia.
As well, Power Roles will tend to be talkative or quiet based on their play type, and both are equally likely to be either because of WIFOM elements.
And so I'd like to eliminate the players that would be passive. Passive players, being honest, are more likely to accidentally sheep the mafia and refuse to form a good opinion themselves.
So basically, everyone should keep talking else I'll maybe push a lynch on you ;]
Passive players are going to be the ones that usually abstain and want to wait til the next day to figure something out, and don't want to take the risk of pointing fingers. As well, they'll most likely sheep other players who seem to know what they are talking about rather than forming their own hard opinion.
The behaviors of both types carry through being mafia, so both quiet and talkative players are likely to be Mafia.
As well, Power Roles will tend to be talkative or quiet based on their play type, and both are equally likely to be either because of WIFOM elements.
And so I'd like to eliminate the players that would be passive. Passive players, being honest, are more likely to accidentally sheep the mafia and refuse to form a good opinion themselves.
So basically, everyone should keep talking else I'll maybe push a lynch on you ;]
In that case I will help you a little hand Defiant_Blob. There's only one person so far that only posted once after Nottycat's death:
Not sure if you want to make something up out of that already, but tossing a ball will get it to roll.
While I can understand that way of thinking my experience with mafia is that this is how the mafia faces most people. I'm not certain you're mafia but I'm gonna vote Jolteon42 so I can turn up the heat.
If you look through all the previous mafia games you'll see that I am always more of the quiet type mafia or villager. Usually mafia is desperate to get the town out of the picture and after a discussion is made they'll usually look at the most quiet person and start to accuse them. This is how I develop an opinion.
True and valid point there.
An easy claim somebody can make though. By no means am I saying that you are mafia but what proof do you have that we can trust you?
Wow, you can immediately make an assumption based on nothing like that? And since, nearly everyone is lynch hungry you're out to rope Jolteon on basically, zilch.
Awesome, we'll take the "point the finger" approach.
Ok, well if we're basing it on someone who hasn't said much, what about 77_is_the_best ?
Awesome, we'll take the "point the finger" approach.
Ok, well if we're basing it on someone who hasn't said much, what about 77_is_the_best ?
That's pretty much all he's had to say... :\
- Status