let's not explode [day 5 - GAME OVER (MAFIA WIN)]
- Thread starter Jivvi
- Start date
i think master's getting flustered over nothing, notty's being notty but i'll hold further judgement until (if at all) we get a cc and i don't even know what to think of jolt since he's barely said anything this day
i also think ltin is relatively clear by way of being un-ccd, aqua is relatively clear because of starting the suspicion on inf and you (hunter) are relatively clear for all the reasons i listed yesterday
if aqua is the real drunk he should just claim tbh, we get a scum out of it and who cares about aqua anyway
tbh i'm just watching the fallout from night 2 and boy is it amusing
I posted once before going to bed and I just woke up.
I think Ender is like 200% town, dunno about Aqua, he's probably leaning towards the town side cause I think he'd be more careful posting if he was Mafia. I can't blame Notty that much considering he shared the same point as I did so thinking of him as suspicious would be kinda hypocritical. Master seems kinda shady and a bit panicky. I'm not suspicious of anyone enough to lynch them just yet.
Also @ender I'm pretty sure Aqua being a drunk is a joke thing, pretty sure he would've CC'd if he really was the drunk.
I think Ender is like 200% town, dunno about Aqua, he's probably leaning towards the town side cause I think he'd be more careful posting if he was Mafia. I can't blame Notty that much considering he shared the same point as I did so thinking of him as suspicious would be kinda hypocritical. Master seems kinda shady and a bit panicky. I'm not suspicious of anyone enough to lynch them just yet.
Also @ender I'm pretty sure Aqua being a drunk is a joke thing, pretty sure he would've CC'd if he really was the drunk.
I WAS SO HAPPY THAT IN MY FIRST MAF GAME WHEN I WAS INNO I MANAGED TO OUT A MAFIA.
WHY ARE YOU GUYS ACTING LIKE I DIDN'T DO ANYTHING. UNDER-APPRECIATED, GG.
Also some of the stuff I said may have been nonsensical, and I apologies, however I am serious about Notty and Ltin so when my headache dies I might actually write up a reason... if it not obvious from their day 1 actions and inffy flipping mafia.
sorry i've been busy catching up on school, and we're going to the coast so idk how long it'll take me to reply again, my phone doesn't have service but i stole my dad's
anyways, i'm not good at giving information and things but I feel master is most sus, although I feel notty could be as well
it's 4am and i'm tired so i won't vote just yet, but i'll try to check back in tomorrow hh
i refuse to lynch an uncc'd PR in an open setup
im kinda tempted to vote kallie or rune since knowing inf voting them when he's practically dead to drive suspicion off is something he would do
b u t im still super susp of notty since how convenient is it that they happen to be the one role where if someone visits them during the night when visiting someone they die and the theory of oak getting result early rests on that
either way with so many power roles claimed or dead the pool of civs are getting quite low which is worrying
#unvote
im kinda tempted to vote kallie or rune since knowing inf voting them when he's practically dead to drive suspicion off is something he would do
b u t im still super susp of notty since how convenient is it that they happen to be the one role where if someone visits them during the night when visiting someone they die and the theory of oak getting result early rests on that
either way with so many power roles claimed or dead the pool of civs are getting quite low which is worrying
#unvote
Can't because I didn't. I'll try and explain the logic. Now I got a result where someone had a visiting action. These are the visiting actions this game and they'd have to be one of these roles:
Town:
Soothsayer.
Drunk.
Maven.
Nurse.
Surgeon.
Mafia:
Gadget.
Quack.
Mafiakill.
Third Party:
Mystery role.
On night 1 the soothsayer died, I didn't visit the soothsayer so I could remove that one from the list. I could also remove the Mafiakill since I didn't visit someone who visited samlem. And it couldn't have been the gadget action since the gadget isn't dead and people didn't explode. Next I honestly doubt that the Mafia would use their 1-time protect during Night 1, I mean honestly they wouldn't. So I could remove quack from the list as well.
That left me with:
Town: Drunk, Maven, Nurse, Surgeon
Third Party: Mystery role.
Ltin claimed drunk and I didn't visit Ltin, so I could remove drunk from my list. Next on Night 2 Oak the Maven died, and again I didn't visit this one so the person I visited wasn't the Maven either. The surgeon should be easy to see as the surgeon has two protects, however the surgeon can decide to use only one(?) so I couldn't exactly count him out for that. Instead I took surgeon of the list because nobody except me visited the person I visited. And if the person I visited was the surgeon, then atleast the nurse should of visited.
Leaving me with:
Town: Nurse
Third Party: Mystery role.
In case the person I visited is the Nurse(which is like an 83% chance), I know who both the Nurse and the Surgeon are. And if not I know who the Third Party is.
Soothsayer.
Drunk.
Maven.
Nurse.
Surgeon.
Mafia:
Gadget.
Quack.
Mafiakill.
Third Party:
Mystery role.
On night 1 the soothsayer died, I didn't visit the soothsayer so I could remove that one from the list. I could also remove the Mafiakill since I didn't visit someone who visited samlem. And it couldn't have been the gadget action since the gadget isn't dead and people didn't explode. Next I honestly doubt that the Mafia would use their 1-time protect during Night 1, I mean honestly they wouldn't. So I could remove quack from the list as well.
That left me with:
Town: Drunk, Maven, Nurse, Surgeon
Third Party: Mystery role.
Ltin claimed drunk and I didn't visit Ltin, so I could remove drunk from my list. Next on Night 2 Oak the Maven died, and again I didn't visit this one so the person I visited wasn't the Maven either. The surgeon should be easy to see as the surgeon has two protects, however the surgeon can decide to use only one(?) so I couldn't exactly count him out for that. Instead I took surgeon of the list because nobody except me visited the person I visited. And if the person I visited was the surgeon, then atleast the nurse should of visited.
Leaving me with:
Town: Nurse
Third Party: Mystery role.
In case the person I visited is the Nurse(which is like an 83% chance), I know who both the Nurse and the Surgeon are. And if not I know who the Third Party is.
And unless you see flaws in my logic, I hope that explains in better detail why I can't exactly say who visited who.
well who's the nurse then
obviously they're not gonna claim 3p plus if the doc protects me plus the nurse then neither the nurse nor the doc can die except through lynch or gadget
and maf gadgeting the nurse would be idiotic
Don't reveal the goddamn doc though but revealing the nurse would help the town
obviously they're not gonna claim 3p plus if the doc protects me plus the nurse then neither the nurse nor the doc can die except through lynch or gadget
and maf gadgeting the nurse would be idiotic
Don't reveal the goddamn doc though but revealing the nurse would help the town
I still don't buy it. Notty's playstyle day 1 just seemed so odd, and considering inf followed her actions so much and she defended inf in reverse. It just doesn't add up to me. From what I learnt Notty is good at mafia, so with that in mind you would expect her to follow up on inf's suspicious behaviour immediately after it had been recognised, but instead she stuck with Hunter and when that didn't work switched to me to try and alleviate suspicion; maybe I am over thinking this but if some1 can CC please do.
