let's not explode [day 5 - GAME OVER (MAFIA WIN)]

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
Points
138
Before I claim (since it's a terrible thing to do), can I just ONCE AGAIN explain CLEARLY what is going on in my famous morgan freeman voice.

*Insert morgan freeman voice for possibly the last time ;_;*

  • People said Ltin is suspicious and wanted to lynch them
  • I disagreed and thought mafia were probably amongst said people trying to kill off ltin because I saw Ltin as Town, so I defended them but made sure I made it clear that I wasn't 100% certain so nobody then put suspicion on me.
  • Meanwhile I have slight, albeit flimsy suspicion on Hunter, but I don't want to speak this suspicion because otherwise people will suspect me of either trying to get a random lynch or being cop.
  • We need 2 more votes for Ltin. Everyone has seen the thread and nobody has said anything. I decide to, one last time, tell people I think we're making a mistake, but since we're not going to realistically vote anyone else, I vote Ltin. Oog offers to hammer.
  • Suddenly Ltin claims Drunk and is uncced. Hunter and Ender make posts saying we should still lynch him.
  • I'm like "whaaat that doesn't make sense but I'll wait for others to post first because I might be misunderstanding something".
  • Notty + oog post about how that also makes 0 sense and say Hunter and Ender are suspicious and vote Hunter.
  • I, having already been suspicious of Hunter and seeing that I was right and that his and ender's post didn't make sense, vote Hunter. I'm also suspicious of Ender but I focus on Hunter because he has more votes on him and I've thought he was suspicious for a while anyway.
  • SUDDENLY Hunter says I'm probably Mafia trying to kill him because I want ltin to stay alive and everyone jumps on board and apparently I've been acting suspicious the entire time because I've defended Ltin and apparently me voting Hunter is 10x more suspicious than everyone else voting hunter, even though we share the same logic behind it.
  • Aqua says something about how I never defended Ltin fully so I'm suspicious or something, and I explain I didn't know Ltin was 100% Town so I didn't defend him 100%, I just defended him with "I think he's innocent (but I could be wrong)" which I think is perfectly reasonable.
  • Suddenly Ender is like "Inf is Mafia because he didn't vote me" or something, which is because I was voting Hunter. Apparently because I didn't say "Ender is suspicious", I'm specifically targeting Hunter because of some underlying motive, even though the reason I didn't say that was because Notty said it for me, to which I said "I agree with Notty", and then focused my arguments with Hunter since he was saying I was mafia.
  • More and more people seem to suddenly jump to kill me for some reason, and Aqua gives me lots of weird questions that don't make much sense. He asks me why I didn't say I was suspicious of Hunter earlier on, to which I respond that I didn't want to be put under suspicion myself because I didn't have reasonable ground to base my suspicion off of; it was just a gut feeling.
  • Hunter claims Civilian
  • Chaos, chaos, chaos
Now can the people who have voted me please tell me exactly why? After reading what happened, why am I suddenly Mafia? For defending someone I thought was innocent and accusing someone I thought suspicious of being Town, something Aqua USES AGAINST ME AS A REASON TO LYNCH ME BECAUSE I DIDN'T ACCUSE HUNTER EARLIER? (Aqua) I am just so confused as to what the hell is happening because I've literally said "actually guys i dont think this person is mafia, i think this person (WHO HAS DONE SOMETHING VERY ANTI-TOWN BY THE WAY) has", suddenly INF = MAFIA, LYNCH, CLAIM OR DIE. So pls someone explain why they are still voting me rather than Hunter, who tried to get a mayor to claim then when people pointed out it was anti-town suddenly revealed it was all a plan to see how Ltin reacted, even though the conversation about Mayor claiming didn't involve ltin in the first place, and who said we should continue to lynch an UN CC PR because the time is almost up.

I'll claim if I have to, but until then I WILL FIGHT
 

Jolterino

'_>'
Mafia Host
Joined
Aug 11, 2011
Messages
1,090
Reaction score
1,931
Points
113
God this is such a shitfest right now, I have no idea how to wrap my mind around this much text in this much time.

First of all Inffy seems to be panicking which might be a sign of him being mafia but also could just be a townie who doesn't want to get lynched. All in all I can't prove anything off of this. I also agree that Inffy might have been too quick to switch to a Hunter but I don't see why if he was mafia the switch would've been made unless Ltin was also mafia?

At this point I'm just going to be randomly voicing things I think are a bit off. 1.) Hunter claims when he's not under that much pressure to be lynched. (5 votes on him, most people voting others recently.) And Hunter who keeps going on about how "you can't just say he's not town just because he claimed Drunk" claims Civ and he asks to get doctor'd and cop'd (if people have doubts). Ooglie instantly unvotes when Hunter claims civ, an unCCable role which literally every Mafia could claim. Ltin also mentions that there was an argument on why Mafia would want to claim Civ but nobody considers Hunter to be Mafia for some reason.

Notty mentions this:

"You do realize that if the cop even does that, not only will we hear the result on Day 3 which is a long while from now I doubt he'd be alive by then, but also he wouldn't be actively hunting for the gadget. I'd rather lynch you now and have the cop try his luck on someone else."
Which I agree 100% with. Maybe he's trying to waste all town PR night actions or the Gadget might blow him up and try to get as many town PR kills as possible (think this is too risky from the mafia's side). Or maybe he's the Gadget who wants to waste night actions THEN martyr the next night to hopefully kill some townies.

With all things considered:


#vote Hunter
 

Samlen

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Nov 1, 2012
Messages
187
Reaction score
353
Points
63
Votecount - The one that's sorta here just as a reminder. Also I don't have the perms to lock a thread so I'll need someone else to do that once deadline hits (If Jivvi isn't on by then)
Hunter - Notty Infected Runemen Jolt (4/8)
Infected - Hunter Aqua Ender Caffeinated (4/8)
Not Voting - Mulbery Kalliee Mastersten Oak Mario Ltin Ooglie (7/15)
15 living so 8 to no-ylnch or lynch
DEADLINE IN 29 MINUTES
 

Ltin

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
951
Reaction score
1,481
Points
93
Jolt has some good points.
As much as I don't want to lynch a civilian claim, it is the easiest role to claim, and it seems like a waste to use a PR action on hunter imo.
Ohh I'm so confused.
Though I'm not sure I understand the whole issue, I don't really think inf is all that suspicious, and I don't know where this ender thing came from, but I don't think he's suspicious either.
 

Jolterino

'_>'
Mafia Host
Joined
Aug 11, 2011
Messages
1,090
Reaction score
1,931
Points
113
Page 15 votecount

Ltin - Hunter Aqua Mario Runemen Ender (5/8)
Hunter - Notty Ooglie Infected (3/8)
Not Voting - Caffeinated Mulbery Jolt Kalliee Ltin Mastersten Oak (7/15)

ltin votes hunter (hunter 4/8)
runemen votes hunter (hunter 5/8)
hunter votes inffy (inffy 1/8) ltin (4/8)
aqua votes inffy (inffy 2/8) (ltin 3/8)
ender votes inffy (inffy 3/8) (ltin 2/8)
mario unvotes (ltin 1/8)
hunter claims
ltin unvotes (hunter 4/8)
ooglie unvotes (hunter 3/8)

caff voted somewhere inbetween
(inffy 4/8)

Maybe it's because I wasn't there at the time reading the posts as they came out but it didn't seem to me like there was that much of a rush on getting you lynched.
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
6,022
Points
138
I'm presuming if it stays Tied like it currently is, a coinflip between Hunter/Inf will be done. I hope by the time the deadline ends(20 min) Hunter has gotten another vote since I really think Inf isn't a good lynch and his "panicking" as you might call it seems to be edging towards towntelling in my opinion.
 

Hunter

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Aug 9, 2011
Messages
2,630
Reaction score
3,023
Points
138
I'm presuming if it stays Tied like it currently is, a coinflip between Hunter/Inf will be done. I hope by the time the deadline ends(20 min) Hunter has gotten another vote since I really think Inf isn't a good lynch and his "panicking" as you might call it seems to be edging towards towntelling in my opinion.
iirc we both get lynched, could be wrong tho
 

Hunter

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Aug 9, 2011
Messages
2,630
Reaction score
3,023
Points
138
you're not confirmed, shut up
i said confirmed civ u nerd
after the cop investigates me


there's literally 0 reason to lynch a civ claim d1 regardless of circumstance unless ur a fucking dumbass
save it for when everyone outs days later in the endgame

unless you want to seriously fuck up the game the first day
 

Ltin

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
951
Reaction score
1,481
Points
93
you're not confirmed, shut up
i said confirmed civ u nerd
after the cop investigates me


there's literally 0 reason to lynch a civ claim d1 regardless of circumstance unless ur a fucking dumbass
save it for when everyone outs days later in the endgame

unless you want to seriously fuck up the game the first day
I didn't say I was confirmed.
You aren't confirmed civilian either?
Why so sure?
There's zero reason to lynch an un CCed PR claim too.
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
Points
138
you're not confirmed, shut up
i said confirmed civ u nerd
after the cop investigates me


there's literally 0 reason to lynch a civ claim d1 regardless of circumstance unless ur a fucking dumbass
save it for when everyone outs days later in the endgame

unless you want to seriously fuck up the game the first day
Anyone could just as easily claim civ and present the same argument.