Lasagne Mafia - Game over

[Infected_alien8_]

Excuse me but even that conspiracy theory is inaccurate.


I explained the possibility of a mafia sided kidnapping first.

That doesn't make the conspiracy theory inaccurate, you'd have known there was that possibility and someone would probably realize it anyway, so you bringing it up just helps you look useful and you still conclude that molten is likely town so it's not going against what your original intention would have

 

[Infected_alien8_]

been

 

[Infected_alien8_]

you'd have known there was that possibility and someone would probably realize it anyway,

and imo likely considered that someone would probably realize it anyway*

 

[Alisha]

That doesn't make the conspiracy theory inaccurate, you'd have known there was that possibility and someone would probably realize it anyway, so you bringing it up just helps you look useful and you still conclude that molten is likely town so it's not going against what your original intention would have

Fair enough, I would probably do such a thing as scum. No argument there.

 

[Unusual_Dood]

tA thing I think not many people have considered is that mafia could kidnap one of their own. The kidnapper role could be used either as a second roleblocker, or to protect a mafia member from being investigated (or shot, but I don't think the mafia would've anticipated a shot N1). With two cops originally in the setup, and the lack of anyone claiming they were kidnapped, I think it's at least reasonably likely that this is what happened.

And the second point, yeah, I hadn't thought of that.

3) What?

That's really a good point which I didn't even consider at all, but could actually be something mafias might have considered.

For 3) I thought of cases where we could assume the PR (after they died and we figured their role) got info that they hinted towards in the thread where we would be fooled. I for instance thought of a case where the cop dies and he highly town read player x day 1, and we could assume that was because he got x town. However, if we knew he got that the cop was kidnapped this would be useful. Not useful in very many cases, but in a few.

After reconsidering what Tim brought up I'm not equally as certain a kidnapped player is innocent as I were, but still think them being town is still more likely.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Fair enough, I would probably do such a thing as scum. No argument there.

It'd also benefit you to point it out so that in future people aren't assumed to be innocent based on them being kidnapped, allowing your team to kidnap people without fear of reducing the lynch pool too much

Tbh the more I think about it the more I realize that the mafia probably realized that kidnapping a townie would make them seem likely town and therefore made a plan based around that but I'm trying not to tunnel vision because when this day started I was walking through a tunnel irl and at the end of it there was a sign in big letters which said 'Tunnel Vision' so I think I'm being warned!

 

[Alisha]

It'd also benefit you to point it out so that in future people aren't assumed to be innocent based on them being kidnapped, allowing your team to kidnap people without fear of reducing the lynch pool too much

Also I was wrong about being first to point out the possibility, Timdood was actually first. Oops.

I think kidnapping information can help supplement reads and other things, and shouldn't be counted as a rule of thumb, of course.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Alisha sounds weirdly formal/serious and I don't like it

Alisha why must I always find you suspicious

 

[Alisha]

Alisha sounds weirdly formal/serious and I don't like it

Alisha why must I always find you suspicious

Every single game you and Brian and others pile on, so once again the question you must ask yourselves is the following;

Does this talented and fabulous trickster share my best interests or not?

 

[Infected_alien8_]

How do you expect mafia to play?

TehBrian

 

[Alisha]

purplepixies please do not post after you have died.

 

[TehBrian]

TehBrian

Infected_alien8_

 

[TehBrian]

Also yeah, Alisha seems oddly serious. In Discord games she's more relaxed and doesn't seem to care much, which usually works in her favor, but whenever she's mafia she always seems very tight and trying to prove herself or use LOGIC and REASONING™

\_o¬o_/

Vote Alisha

 

[Alisha]

Also yeah, Alisha seems oddly serious. In Discord games she's more relaxed and doesn't seem to care much, which usually works in her favor, but whenever she's mafia she always seems very tight and trying to prove herself or use LOGIC and REASONING™

\_o¬o_/

Vote Alisha

It's almost as if we're playing a forum game that only happens once every couple of months or so as opposed to werewolf games where the game ends after several minutes of memeing

 

[TehBrian]

It's almost as if we're playing a forum game that only happens once every couple of months or so as opposed to werewolf games where the game ends after several minutes of memeing

It's almost as if you're getting weirdly defensive and somewhat angry at the fact that I'm even proposing you might be Mafia.

 

[Alisha]

It's almost as if you're getting weirdly defensive and somewhat angry at the fact that I'm even proposing you might be Mafia.

How dare I actually defend myself instead of rolling over and letting people lynch me whenever they get bored!!

 

[Timdood3]

Yeah, I have to side with Alisha on this one. It kind of feels like Brian is grasping at straws to implant the idea that Alisha is mafia into the rest of our heads. Like throwing a handful of darts and seeing if he can get any to stick.

 

[TehBrian]

I don't. I'm always suspicious of Alisha, and Inffy agrees with this on me. Alisha is being uptight and no matter what she never seems this way.

 

[Alisha]

I don't. I'm always suspicious of Alisha, and Inffy agrees with this on me. Alisha is being uptight and no matter what she never seems this way.

Uptight about what?

 

[TehBrian]

Uptight about what?

You're being uptight. It's like saying you're sad. I'm not sure what about, but you just ARE being uptight. You're too formal or serious or something.

 

[MoltenAshes]

You're being uptight. It's like saying you're sad. I'm not sure what about, but you just ARE being uptight. You're too formal or serious or something.

U
Is it just me, or does it seem like you're being quite jumpy to lynch someone over very little. You voted for Inffy as well which was quite questionable.

 

[MoltenAshes]

Lol "U" mobile these days.

 

[Timdood3]

You're being uptight. It's like saying you're sad. I'm not sure what about, but you just ARE being uptight. You're too formal or serious or something.

I'm formal and serious, and could be classified as uptight.
Why aren't you accusing me?

Is it because you've seen her be casual in other settings (i.e. discord)?

Forum mafia and discord mafia are two entirely different beasts. Any game of mafia I've seen outside of a forum, for example, are over in a matter of minutes, and you'll get another chance within the hour. Forum mafia, on the other hand, takes weeks. And with the slower pace, it naturally lends itself toward being more serious and cautious because it feels like you have more to lose.

 

[TehBrian]

Lol "U" mobile these days.

Sorry, yeah. On Discord werewolf you can see pretty clearly though I'm always weary of Inffy, but he seems alright this time around. That's why I went on Alisha.

 

[Timdood3]

Long story short, you can't generalize someone's behaviors from one setting and expect them to be the same in another, because the factors going into their behavior won't be the same.