Hectic Hawaii (Game Over)

[Duffie]

I doubt that means 7 mafia.

I mean, if you think about it, 7/10, already a majority. So, obviously not. xD

I think there's either 3 or 4 mafia, and the rest of the 7 is third party.

 

[Duffie]

(or maybe we can all agree that your role in one mafia game has nothing to do with the one you get in another)

(At least, you hope, because you never want to get Cop again.)

 

[Enderfive]

I think there's either 3 or 4 mafia, and the rest of the 7 is third party.

Explain, now.

 

[Duffie]

Explain, now.

I just said, it would make it not a majority. o. o

3 or 4 to 7 or 8. Makes it harder on mafia. xD

 

[Nottykitten]

(well the thing about Ender being the better choice was obviously not anything serious)

Though I think the 7 standing out probabily means 7 town and 3 mafia. But that would be weird since I'd expect there to be a third party or even two. So maybe those 7 outstanding people are the Non-Mafia's.

 

[Enderfive]

I just said, it would make it not a majority. o. o

3 or 4 to 7 or 8. Makes it harder on mafia. xD

How come you didn't include any town in your predictions?

 

[Duffie]

(well the thing about Ender being the better choice was obviously not anything serious)

Though I think the 7 standing out probabily means 7 town and 3 mafia. But that would be weird since I'd expect there to be a third party or even two. So maybe those 7 outstanding people are the Non-Mafia's.

I'm not saying the 3 not spoken of are mafia. xD

Let's look at what was said;

Recently, there has been an influx of tourists in Ewa Beach, Hawaii. It's not uncommon for tourists to arrive, but it is an unusual time of year for it. [hl]Seven guests stand out among the locals. [/hl]Some fear they have harmful intent, though others simply look upon them as they would any tourists. After all, no one needs a specific reason to go on vacation, right?

Based on this, that makes it clear there are only 3 town, and leaving 7 guests. These guests range from mafia to third party.

My guess is that mafia takes up 3 ~ 4 players, due to the fact that would make it harder on the mafia, as if there were 5 mafia, simply getting rid of one non-mafia would be a victory... Which is a bit weird, you must admit.

 

[Duffie]

How come you didn't include any town in your predictions?

And I guess I just answered your question in my top post. xD

 

[Enderfive]

My guess is that mafia takes up 3 ~ 4 players, due to the fact that would make it harder on the mafia, as if there were 5 mafia, simply getting rid of one non-mafia would be a victory...

There cannot be 5 mafia, because they'd already won the game by now in that case. 4 mafia would make it a MyLo from the start.

2-3 mafia seems more likely to me.

 

[Duffie]

There cannot be 5 mafia, because they'd already won the game by now in that case. 4 mafia would make it a MyLo from the start.

2-3 mafia seems more likely to me.

Oh, the more you know.

2~3 mafia sounds better, then, because I totally didn't account equal being a mafia victory. xD

My bad.

So, looking at it now...

Town ~ 3
Mafia ~ 2~3
Third Party ~ 4~5

Looks like it's a third-party heavy match. ;o

 

[Enderfive]

Oh, the more you know.

2~3 mafia sounds better, then, because I totally didn't account equal being a mafia victory. xD

My bad.

So, looking at it now...

Town ~ 3
Mafia ~ 2~3
Third Party ~ 4~5

Looks like it's a third-party heavy match. ;o

No, but seriously, where do you take the assumption that there are that many Third Parties in the game?

 

[Duffie]

No, but seriously, where do you take the assumption that there are that many Third Parties in the game?

Well, look at the mafia count and town count. The town count is sure, and the mafia count is assumed, what else is left..?

 

[Ltin]

I think you guys might be overthinking it. Just assume you have no real idea.

 

[Enderfive]

Well, look at the mafia count and town count. The town count is sure, and the mafia count is assumed, what else is left..?

And how is the town count sure?

 

[Duffie]

And how is the town count sure?

Look at the opening paragraph. o. o

Unless the locals are the mafia for whatever reason, then they must be town.

 

[Duffie]

I think you guys might be overthinking it. Just assume you have no real idea.

We probably are overthinking it, but it makes for some good conversation, does it not?

 

[Fiestaguy]

Everything could be possible. Heck, maybe tim went so insanes to have two mafia parties both with 2 people .-. We can't really assume anything for now. But the chance of lynching mafia if there are 3-4 members is 30-40%. We'd actually be best off no-lynching imo .-.

Vote no-lunch

 

[Ltin]

Vote no-lunch

No. I want lunch.

 

[Fiestaguy]

Vote no-lunch

 

[Enderfive]

Look at the opening paragraph. o. o

Unless the locals are the mafia for whatever reason, then they must be town.

It's flavour text. You can't take it for a fact. Yes, I did notice it and I did think about what it could mean (and frankly, I quite dislike mods putting in "hints" like that in flavour text) and it could mean that there are three people in one "group", so to say. Or it could just be Tim messing with us. We don't know and can't know for sure, that's all I'm saying. Assumptions are no good in Mafia, especially in a closed setup game, so could we please not do that?

Also, why no lunch, Fiesta? :c

 

[Duffie]

It's flavour text. You can't take it for a fact. Yes, I did notice it and I did think about what it could mean (and frankly, I quite dislike mods putting in "hints" like that in flavour text) and it could mean that there are three people in one "group", so to say. Or it could just be Tim messing with us. We don't know and can't know for sure, that's all I'm saying. Assumptions are no good in Mafia, especially in a closed setup game, so could we please not do that?

Well, what else is there to do, but assume and presume what could be possible..?

It's the beginning of the days and nights to come, so there isn't really much to do but either vote, or talk amongst ourselves about what could be possible.

We're only left up to what has been previously said, and that's what I've been going by. As you, and everyone else, begins to piece things together, we can win this.

 

[Fiestaguy]

NO LUNCH. FUCK LUNCH.
Altough I kinda don't know what tim really means by 'Stood out' (Maybe the seven people stood out because they wore clownsuits or look like dodgy men in their mid-forties scratching their bears, making snorting sounds at every woman they see?) It might be a distraction. Who knows. 0.0

 

[Nottykitten]

Assumptions are no good in Mafia, especially in a closed setup game, so could we please not do that?

Assumptions are the only thing we can do in a closet setup game, since we know nothing else x)

 

[Fiestaguy]

Assumptions are the only thing we can do in a closet setup game, since we know nothing else x)

'Closet setup' that's partially true, because a Cop might show up, or someone clams something. Or the host goes insane.

 

[Ltin]

So I think ill just
vote no lynch because im bored and want to get this going.