[Game Over] Just Your Average Mafia Game
- Thread starter Ltin
- Start date
- Status
yeah I'd expect him to have at least given a thought on the Joe discussion or say something like 'I'm here' so to just enter with a direct question about what the doc can do felt really sort of... lazer focused on avoiding small talk that could get him caught out kind of? Idk how to explain it again
I said underneath that I meant to delete that part since I changed my mind
weak town read i get since you know him well, im interested in what you would have scumread me for otherwise, and also why do you townread comp while you scumread hkcaper when both have been very quiet
yeah i dont understand why he would ask that either because the assumption here is doc has free reign on targets except for themselves, if it deviated from that we would have been told beforehand
oops
also im done playing around because there have been games where all of us have worked together much better than this and several people are being much less useful than usual, if you're town and doing this then just uh, stop i guess
here let me do another!
(disclaimer: I already think tim's mafia based on how he's wording his posts and stuff so I'm probably biased in how I interpret all of this but just wanted to throw it out there)
Tim thinks I'm town since he thinks I'm picking up on his nerves which is a real thing (also as a quick aside that I wasn't gonna point out initially since it felt like such a tiny point but I feel like pointing it out now: note the 'If you're not town, then that means you're doing this thing, which frankly isn't like you' sentence which is basically saying 'if you're scum then you're doing scum things and that's not like you as town', it just feels really odd to have that thought process and I think is a symptom of not being properly in the scumhunt mindset)
Stranger restates her suspicion on me after backing off earlier, making it clear she's still suspicious of me despite unvoting me previously
TWG scum reads me
UNU says he's unsure of me
Suddenly tim thinks I'm mafia again because my 'relentlessness does not speak well to' him, conveniently after seeing 3 people seem slightly ok with lynching me. Idk, I feel like tim knows I can be pretty relentless as town, so I don't buy that this is a genuine change of heart here and it seems more like 'oh inf is still mislynchable, I'll change my mind again'
Oh and another thing that keeps bothering me (that is probably just confirmation bias but I'll share it anyway in case someone else can see it too) is how he responds when he's suspected. It feels like he's putting a lot of effort into not stepping onto any toes with his responses, to the point where it seems out of character for townie tim.
This is where I first got the impression he was being cautious not to step on my toes but I didn't say anything at the time since I was aware I was probably just confirmation biasing but again I'm just gonna throw it out there. I think town tim would instead say "What seems fake about it? Surely it's more substantial than gut feelings.' or something (only a tiny difference word-wise but changes the feel of the post a whole lot to me - the way he posted it feels like he's not wanting to get into an argument with me at all since he's scared of getting too much attention, which I don't think he'd be scared of as town)
And his response later on when he talked about him being nervous and thinking I'm town felt like he was doing his best to avoid a scuffle with me as well, rather than trying to genuinely pick apart my read and see if I was town or not
The level of OMGUS in this post is too damn high. This isn't a level of defensiveness id expect from Tim. Also, it's worth noting he never voted himself at the start of this game, which he also forgot to do the last time he was mafia.
Vote Timdoood3
Mainly the claim that Comp would be a "nice kill". There's something about that phrasing that strikes me as off. That said, if Tim does flip scum I'd be more inclined to believe you're town.
Thought a bit about it and I think it's best for us to lynch today. If we lynch scum then that's good - and if we mislynch there's still a chance that scum hits scum tonight. And even if scum doesn't kill another scum tonight we will still (sorta) have a lynch tomorrow as scum can't out themselves because then the other scum would die.
Agree, but it doesn't necessarily mean that he's town.
I mean the fact that he earlier suspected you, but then you claimed and were town which meant that Stranger was scum, like totally out of the blue. May be that I'm tunnelvisioning here but I really, really feel that inffy is scum. It's all vibes, but usually when Inffy is town I find him somewhat agreeable; however this game (especially after that post) I've felt like I've disagreed with much of what Inffy has said. (I don't agree in that he can determine if Comp, Sessy and HKC is scum after having >3 posts each)
!
I already said, I said he'd be a nice kill to see how you'd react to it since you seemed a bit jumpy at me voting for him, so I was testing whether you might be teammates and if you'd get defensive over him. I wouldn't try to kill someone who hasn't spoken for the sole reason that they seem like a 'nice kill', the vote wasn't me trying to kill anyone, it was just to throw a stone in the water to watch the ripples
I claimed she was town because she claimed cop
I said stranger was scum since the way I felt about her changed, I wasn't 100% sure why but I tried to have a go at guessing why in that post
woops first quote messed up but I meant to respond to:
!
(I completely forgot about that, pretty good point tbh, could easily just be an unfortunate coincidence and he just forgot since he hasn't played for a while but there's definitely a tiny pattern emerging - not that I think we should use that argument to lynch him of course)
with
!
(I completely forgot about that, pretty good point tbh, could easily just be an unfortunate coincidence and he just forgot since he hasn't played for a while but there's definitely a tiny pattern emerging - not that I think we should use that argument to lynch him of course)
Inffy scumread me and townread stranger before my claim, based on that I would be too careful to link myself with a mafia buddy early on - this flipped when i claimed which seems reasonable imo
- Status