(as in she wanted to say it to make hip seem townie to get people to back off but didnt think people would actually work out that he was cop specifically, just that hed softclaimed a town role somewhere)
[Concluded] The Party at the Machine
- Thread starter Timdood3
- Start date
- Status
(oh and i feel like i made it pretty clear i knew hip was possibly cop yesterday as well so why would i do that if i wanted to pretend i hadnt seen it and bus poke for credit! saying this since i just realized you did point out we could've seen you were cop before i actually posted that i had seen it so my argument previously wouldnt work but this one does!)
Vote poke
Though I'd like to know what pokes plan as cop would be so we can have a fall back in case he is cop. Just doesn't sound too convincing to me I agree with Infected_alien8_ view on that. But knowing who you consider scum before is nice to move forward with.
Though I'd like to know what pokes plan as cop would be so we can have a fall back in case he is cop. Just doesn't sound too convincing to me I agree with Infected_alien8_ view on that. But knowing who you consider scum before is nice to move forward with.
he said he got boooo as anti town so id stab hip + we lynch boooo tomorrow
also though before we hammer him Ltin im coming for you tonight unless you convince me otherwise so you might want to consider claiming <3
What's your reason for litin?
Also we got any reads on comp?
Mischief said they were 3p? Is that correct?
since basically all his posts feel weird/empty/random/forced to be a certain way to me
comp idk hes always inactive
mis's claim was that they visit someone and if that person visits the machine that night they set off an alarm, and that they win if they set off an alarm twice on two different people
they said theyd visit me last night since i said i would visit the machine and then today an alarm was set off on the first post of the day so that part of their claim at least seems legit (unless she can just create a custom message for daystart)
Interesting, do you have any claim as to why you visit the machine?
And cool so mis is either 3p or some sort of watcher role that could potentially be sided.
Seems more 3p though but they coulda made it sound that way for convienece but that's just me trying to find an opposition and it's not strong lol
Sorry kinda been a long week, have been keeping up but haven't had the time to post
I pretty much entirely believe hip about their claim - there wouldn't be any reason to lie considering they only got one result. I assume they thought mafia sussed them because of getting no result on inf which probably was a block and so wanted to give the result just in case. Poke just comes across as cagey and its a little to convenient the whole "well actually im the cop" thing and wasnt particularly believable.
If there is a doc role I'd definitely protect hip tonight
I'd hammer poke rn but I do want to wait and see if there's any more discussion about the whole doll thing and also who inf should probably knife (esp as we've got essentially two lynches with it) so need to decide who the next scum is likely to be. (For the record Id say ltin rn)
I pretty much entirely believe hip about their claim - there wouldn't be any reason to lie considering they only got one result. I assume they thought mafia sussed them because of getting no result on inf which probably was a block and so wanted to give the result just in case. Poke just comes across as cagey and its a little to convenient the whole "well actually im the cop" thing and wasnt particularly believable.
If there is a doc role I'd definitely protect hip tonight
I'd hammer poke rn but I do want to wait and see if there's any more discussion about the whole doll thing and also who inf should probably knife (esp as we've got essentially two lynches with it) so need to decide who the next scum is likely to be. (For the record Id say ltin rn)
time to do a comedy club and tag everyone incase doctor is an inactive and hip megadies tonight
Enderfive Mooglie Ltin HKCaper Nottykitten hipmeow Infected_alien8_ Boooo Mischief Jacethegray Comp
hello if you are the doctor protect hip tonight (im almost certain poke is mafia watcher/tracker so it should be safe?) thanks
Enderfive Mooglie Ltin HKCaper Nottykitten hipmeow Infected_alien8_ Boooo Mischief Jacethegray Comp
hello if you are the doctor protect hip tonight (im almost certain poke is mafia watcher/tracker so it should be safe?) thanks
Interesting so we have at least 2 3p we know of. And 1 3p dead. So should be 2-4 more 3p. And we have a number of town (probly 6-8 3 of which are dead) and a number of mafia probably 4-6?
So we have a game plan assuming this does alright and if it doesn't its not the worst case and have a psudo plan for that as well.
So we have a game plan assuming this does alright and if it doesn't its not the worst case and have a psudo plan for that as well.
Okay well that means we have an alarm and a creepy and one dead right?
I have an objection!
Under what situation is the person CCing your role not the best choice? (Hint: it is the one where you are scum and you don't want the real cop to be lynched, revealing your scumness)
In case you cant tell, I don't believe this claim.
I guess that holds (though I don't see why we should exclude the possibility of a bus even if it is mafia starting the BW). But IMO you still cant ascertain any alignment from voting people w/o evidence. That just doesn't strike me as a townie thing to do.
Just because there is good reason to think you're town doesnt mean you get to be immune from criticism.
Except I wasn't caught all the way up!
Also can I just say it is homecoming week and I will be occupied pretty much all of Saturday so I probably wont be around for the deadline. (The deadline is Saturday right?)
Can you rephrase this into smaller sentences please? I cant tell what you are saying here...
I mean that is somewhat normal. I have a hard time following in the beginning of games a lot of the time.
I feel like doing a reads list, but I have to leave for a rehearsal soon so it wont be much. Standby.
OK Reads list (This is what comes to mind atm; I don't have time to go back and look at all my bookmarks and stuff (I still think that is a great forum feature))
Inf - Weak Scum - Inf's reads seem manufactured to me. A lot of his reactions to posts amount to either repeating a phrase he has already used, or simply saying "This feels scummy to me," the latter of which strikes me as unhelpful at best.
Notty - Very Weak Scum - Something about Notty and inf just screams "we are on the same team" to me.
Poke - Scum - I mean I don't believe his claim so this should be somewhat self explanatory.
Hip - Town - wow what a shocker I bet you cant guess why using only the information above.
Jace - Weak Town - His posts are hard to read but he seems to be genuinely trying to contribute. This is mostly vibes though.
Mis - This isn't a read I just don't recall what mis claimed.
Inf - Weak Scum - Inf's reads seem manufactured to me. A lot of his reactions to posts amount to either repeating a phrase he has already used, or simply saying "This feels scummy to me," the latter of which strikes me as unhelpful at best.
Notty - Very Weak Scum - Something about Notty and inf just screams "we are on the same team" to me.
Poke - Scum - I mean I don't believe his claim so this should be somewhat self explanatory.
Hip - Town - wow what a shocker I bet you cant guess why using only the information above.
Jace - Weak Town - His posts are hard to read but he seems to be genuinely trying to contribute. This is mostly vibes though.
Mis - This isn't a read I just don't recall what mis claimed.
- Status